Read: 9 mins.
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Need for Power

In an emergency, we could find ourselves stranded with no electricity in a World that is consuming much more power today than ever before. Just in the past year alone, the globe was hit with numerous fires, earthquakes, hurricanes, tornadoes, tsunamis, and even riots! Solar panels were installed in our home earlier this year during the COVID-19 pandemic that resulted in grid power staying shut for nearly the entire day while the family had to work from home and do distance learning. Then there was a time when my son and I went backpacking in the Sierra Wilderness after camping out in 106F degree heat the night before, kept cool by a small fan and ice making machine.

Generators vs Battery Power Stations

Jackery and Goal Zero

There are numerous ways that electricity can be produced for businesses, emergencies, or recreational use. This article will go over three of the most popular ones: gas and propane generators and lithium-ion battery power stations. Which one is best for you? It depends on your needs.

I am personally not a fan of gas or propane generators, but there are many advantages they have over battery power stations. In my home, we have a Goal Zero Yeti 1500x and Jackery Explorer 1000 lithium-ion battery power stations, and my dad has a Honda EU2200i (1800W – 2200W) gas generator. I use my batteries for camping and road trips, and my dad uses his Honda to run a portable air conditioner during a power outage in 105F degree weather.

Where generators create electricity using a fuel source, such as gasoline or propane, battery power stations store energy obtained from AC outlets, solar panels, and even generators. The key for power stations is that they store electricity, but marketers misleadingly refer to them as battery or solar “generators”.

Power Output

The amount of power generated is measured in Watts (W) and the amount of power stored by a battery is in Watt Hours (Wh):

  • The higher the Wattage, the more electric devices can be powered. A typical RV, for example, uses an average of 3,000W, whereas a laptop may only need 80W
  • The higher the Watt Hours (applicable to batteries only), the longer the electric devices can stay running

A gas, propane, or battery power station may, for instance, output 1,000W of power, and a battery may be able to store 2,000 Wh of energy used to output that 1,000W.

Example: Goal Zero Yeti 500x has a battery capacity of 500 Wh and outputs 300W continuously. If it outputs 300W at all times, it would run out of power after 1.67 hours (500 Wh / 300W).

With all three sources of energy, you will usually find the “rated” and “surge” wattage. What are the differences?

Rated vs Surge Wattage

Electronic devices always start at a higher wattage than when they are already turned on and running. For example, a miter saw can use 2,100W when turned on (surge), but once it is running, it only uses 800W (rated). In short, the rated wattage is when the appliance is already running, and the surge occurs upon power on.

Rated is also known as running or continuous, and surge can also be referred to as starting or peak wattage.

Camping with a laptop and monitor

Let’s use the Goal Zero Yeti 500x battery to illustrate the difference. It is rated for 300W with a peak of 1,200W.

Running Power (Rated)

  • A TV that uses 100W can be used with the Yeti 500x because it consumes less than 300W
    • Up to 200W more devices can be added for as long as they do not exceed 300W combined. You could, for example, connect two more 100W televisions
  • An 800W miter saw, on the other hand, because it exceeds 300W, cannot be used. The battery will not be able to produce more than 300W continuously

Starting Power (Surge)

A generator or power station’s surge rating allows it to temporarily accommodate a device up to that level for a very short amount of time — usually for just a few seconds.

  • A gaming computer may use 290W with a maximum of 600W during power-on or intense gaming
    • Its starting power is 600W and below the Yeti 500x’s 1,200W peak. It is able to be turned on
    • Once powered on, the computer then runs at a continuous 290W. Because this is within the Yeti 500x’s rated 300W, it is able to stay on

Warning: Some batteries are so well-designed, they can run devices at higher than the rated wattage for a longer period of time, but that can severely shorten the lifespan of the battery. You should always try to stay at or below the rated capacity of a generator or battery.

Operating Cost

Generators have a lower, initial cost of investment: they are far less expensive to purchase for the same amount of power put out by batteries. The 7,500W Westinghouse Wgen7500DF dual-fuel generator, for example, costs $1,060, whereas a 2,000W Goal Zero Yeti 3000x costs $3,200 and the 2,000W Goal Zero Yeti 6000x goes for a whopping $5,000!

On the flip side, generators will require a lot of maintenance over batteries, and so the cost saved at the beginning may add up more over the long run in maintenance expenses.

Westinghouse WGen7500DF Dual Fuel Portable Generator /Westinghouse

Gas vs Propane Generators

PROS for Gasoline over Propane

  • Gas is more easily available since gas stations are everywhere
  • More efficient energy production
    • Higher BTU (heat) production per gallon of fuel (by about 30%), making gas cheaper to operate than propane
  • Less expensive to own
  • Smaller, more portable
  • Most popular type of generator
  • More reliable in cold climates (propane tank regulators are susceptible to freezing)
  • Usually have on-board fuel tanks (Propane tends to be in exterior tanks)

CONS against Gasoline over Propane

  • Highly flammable and riskier to store near a home
  • Louder than propane generators
  • Dirtier-burning than propane
  • Worse for the environment and more harmful to humans and pets
  • Worse for generator’s lifespan due to a higher release amount of toxins and carbon deposits in the engine
  • Gas has shorter shelf life than propane (degrades after about 1 year)
    • Even if not used, gas needs to be replaced every so often (every 6 months)
    • Propane does not expire, but the propane tank does at around 12 years
  • In a disaster, gas stations may cease operation, and you would be out of gas
    • Gas is higher in demand during emergencies
  • Propane is stored in cylinders that can last and be stored for a long time near your home

Jackery Explorer 1000 with SolarSaga 100W

Gas Generators vs Battery Power Stations

PROS for Gasoline over Battery

  • Can run virtually forever for as long as fuel is available
    • Battery power stations will eventually run out. They can be recharged via solar panels, but that will depend on sun availability
  • Longer shelf life than batteries
    • Lithium-ion batteries have a lifespan of 500 cycles. They will continue to operate past that, but efficiency will start to degrade by about 20% for every 500 cycles
  • Much cheaper upfront than batteries, but maintenance cost may negate that over time

CONS against Gasoline over Battery

  • Should NEVER be operated indoor or in partially-enclosed areas (even with ventilation)
    • Carbon monoxide gets generated and can kill you
  • Must be kept at least 3′ from any structure during use
    • Battery power stations can be used anywhere, even inside or next to a house (or car!)
    • Fuel is highly flammable, toxic, and bad for the environment and your health
  • Fuel is continuously consumed even if no power is needed by any plugged-in devices
    • A battery power station only outputs the amount of power that connected devices require. If nothing is needed, the battery sits there idle with little to no loss of power
  • Runs louder (battery stations run nearly silent and can be used throughout the night at camp sites)
    • Cannot be used past a certain time at camp sites (usually 10pm)
    • Some generators operate fairly quietly at 59 dB, such as the Champion 3400W Dual-Fuel
  • Constant maintenance required (ie. changing of fuel every 3-6 months)
  • Gasoline may not be available during emergencies
  • Not as portable as battery power stations
    • Requires more care to transport
    • More cumbersome to take on camping trips

Dual-Fuel Generators: Gas AND Propane

There is a breed of generators available that can use both gasoline and propane as their fuel source. This gives you the best of both worlds:

  • Option to power by gas or propane (LPG) through a simple switch (usually)
    • Flexibility to choose whichever fuel source is available during an emergency (gas stations tend to run out first)
    • Propane is safer to store near a home whereas gas is more efficient
      • You can choose which fuel type you want to use for the task at hand
  • Keep in mind that Propane is less efficient than Gas, outputting less Wattage
  • Some generators also including a lithium-ion battery to charge mobile devices without the engine running

Jump Start Car?

Genius Boost GB40 in Use /NOCO

Genius Boost GB40 in Use /NOCO

Neither a gas/propane generator nor battery power station can be used to jump start a car. Instead, I suggest getting a small, portable one specifically made for that, such as my favorite: NOCO Genius Boost Car Jump Starter (Lithium Battery).

Tips

To learn about lithium-ion battery power stations, please refer to my reviews for the excellent Goal Zero Yeti 1500x and Jackery Explorer 1000.

  • When my family had solar panels installed onto the roof of our home, our power was shut off for nearly the entire day. We were working from home while our son was participating in distance learning during the COVID-19 pandemic
  • The Yeti 500x, Explorer 1000, and a pair of Jackery SolarSaga 100W solar panels provided us with enough power to keep the internet alive while running multiple laptops, monitors, and the 53qt Costway EP24413 / 54qt Foho BCD-52 car freezer with our infant’s precious milk

The value of having an alternate source of power is insurmountable in today’s interconnected World filled with conveniences.

Euhomy Ice Maker powered by Jackery Explorer 1000

Gas Generator Usage

  • If you do not know how to use a generator, ask someone who does
    • Incorrect usage could cause damage, injury, and/or death to the engine, you, your home and devices, and even your neighbors/utility workers outside!
  • Buy fuel in smaller quantities and store in clean containers
    • Less chances of all fuel getting contaminated
    • Best fuel: unleaded gasoline with less than 10% added ethanol (check your owner’s manual for the best fuel mix to use with your generator)
      • Never use E85 fuel. Don’t mix oil with gasoline
  • When engine is in use, change its oil after the first 5 hours, then every 50 hours
  • Change engine oil every 3-6 months or add a fuel stabilizer
    • Gasoline deteriorates after a year and can damage your engine over time if not changed
  • Change air filter once a year to maintain efficiency

Gas Generator Safety

  • ALWAYS make sure you ground the generator to minimize electrocution risk!
    • Use #8 size wire to connect the generator’s Ground Terminal to a ground source (ie. metal underground water pipe that is at least 8’ into the earth)
  • Never start/stop engine with electric devices plugged in and turned on
  • Be aware that the starter cord can retract rapidly and pull your hand/arm toward the engine faster than you can let go
  • Never add fuel while the engine is hot or running as it could ignite
  • Do not overfill the fuel tank so the fuel can expand
    • Overflowing fuel can ignite when spilled against the hot engine
  • Do not store fuel in the house as they are highly flammable
    • You should not smoke near it
  • Fuel in the engine’s tank degrades over time. It should be replaced every 6 months even if it was never used
  • Never plug the generator into a wall outlet to “back feed” electricity into the house to power your appliances
    • This is EXTREMELY DANGEROUS and can electrocute utility workers and neighbors served by the same utility transformer
    • To power appliances in the house, have a licensed electrician install the right equipment for the generator to be plugged in to! THIS IS IMPORTANT!
  • Never cover the generator when in use to minimize overheating
  • Generator should be used on a level surface
  • Don’t use in wet/damp conditions (ie. rain) as you could get electrocuted

CAUTION: Never plug a gas or propane generator into a wall outlet to power the house. This is considered “back feeding” and can electrocute utility workers and neighbors saved by the same utility transformer. A licensed electrician should install the proper equipment for the generator to be plugged in to

Calculations

The below calculations are rough estimates as conditions, quality, and product age can vary.

How many Watts does a device use?

  • Calc: Watts used by device = Voltage x Amperage
  • If a vacuum is 120V and 9.5A, it uses 1,140W

How long does it take to charge a device?

  • Calc: Hours to charge device = Device’s battery capacity (Wh) / Input Wattage
  • If a laptop accepts 60W of input and its battery capacity is 550 Wh, it could take 9.2 hrs to charge (550 Wh / 60W)

Summary

Portable Battery Power Stations

A gas/propane generator is significantly cheaper than any lithium-ion battery power station I could find for the same amount of rated output. It provides for a much lower, initial investment for emergency operation, but one should keep in mind the overall maintenance work and cost that comes with gas and/or propane generator use (less so with the latter). With a high amount of output, such as 9,000W, an entire house could be powered with the proper, electrical equipment installed by a licensed technician. Dual-Fuel generators also provide the ability to choose between gas or propane for added versatility when one fuel source is not available during an emergency situation. Furthermore, as long as gasoline or propane is readily available, the generator can virtually run forever with proper maintenance.

My camping needs point me towards lithium-ion portable battery stations. I prefer them because they are very small and light, run silently without any toxic fumes, and can be operated indoors (like cars and tents). Recall that battery power stations do not generate electricity, but rather just store them. As such, once the battery is out, it is out. You may add solar panels to keep them charged, but unlike gas and propane generators, those panels will only work effectively when the sun is out.

The best source of electricity — as stated at the beginning — will depend entirely on what your needs are.

Where To Buy

Related Posts